Common Types of Restrictive Covenant and Their Impact
User covenants restrict the use of the property to a specific purpose, most commonly a single private dwelling house. These are extremely common and cause problems when a homeowner has run a business from the property, converted part of it into a separate letting unit, or changed the use in some other way. A breach of a user covenant can make the property unmortgageable until the breach is addressed, either by ceasing the offending use or (if the breach is historic) by obtaining indemnity insurance.
Development and alteration covenants prevent the construction of new buildings or the alteration of existing structures. Where a homeowner has built an extension, converted a loft, erected outbuildings or carried out other building works without the consent of the covenant beneficiary, this constitutes a breach. If the breach is relatively old (typically more than 12 months) and there is no evidence that the covenant beneficiary has taken any steps to enforce it, restrictive covenant indemnity insurance is usually available and acceptable to lenders.
Covenant to contribute to costs (sometimes called positive covenants) require the property owner to contribute to shared costs such as road maintenance, shared drainage or shared service infrastructure. These are not strictly restrictive covenants (as they impose positive obligations rather than restrictions) but they can affect mortgageability if they are not adequately documented, if the obligation is unusually onerous, or if there is a dispute about contributions. Lenders will want to understand the extent of any ongoing financial obligations before proceeding.
Restrictive Covenant Indemnity Insurance
Restrictive covenant indemnity insurance is the most commonly used remedy for covenant breach in the residential conveyancing and remortgage context. It is a one-off premium policy that protects the property owner and their mortgage lender against the financial consequences of a covenant being enforced. It does not remove the covenant or legalise the breach, but it provides a financial cushion should the covenant beneficiary ever take legal action.
The premium for restrictive covenant indemnity insurance is typically a single payment based on the insured property value and the nature and severity of the breach. Premiums can range from less than £100 for a relatively minor or long-standing breach on a modest property, to several thousand pounds for more recent or serious breaches on higher-value properties. The policy should be obtained in the joint names of the property owner and the lender, and the lender's solicitors will require sight of the policy before releasing any mortgage advance.
For indemnity insurance to be available, the breach must generally be at least 12 months old and there must be no evidence of the covenant beneficiary having taken steps to enforce it (known as "not having put the beneficiary on notice"). Critically, you must not contact the covenant beneficiary or make any approach to them before obtaining the insurance, as this could alert them to the breach and prevent insurance being available. If you are in any doubt, instruct a specialist conveyancer before taking any steps.