Rated Excellent Online
58,000+ Homeowners Helped

Fixed vs Variable Rate Secured Loans

Choosing between a fixed and variable rate secured loan is one of the most important decisions you will make. This guide explains how each rate type works, the risks and benefits of each, and the circumstances in which variable rate borrowing can be the smarter choice.

£283 Avg. monthly saving
90+ UK lenders compared
4-8 weeks Typical completion
Start here

How Fixed Rate Secured Loans Work

A fixed rate secured loan charges a set interest rate for the full term of the loan, or for a defined initial period such as two or five years. Your monthly payment is calculated at the outset and remains exactly the same throughout the fixed period, regardless of what happens to Bank of England base rate or wider market conditions. This gives you complete certainty over your outgoings, which is particularly valuable if you are budgeting tightly or if you rely on a fixed income.

Most fixed rate secured loans are fixed for the entire term rather than reverting to a standard variable rate as mortgages often do. This is a key structural difference from residential mortgages and means that the rate you agree at the start is the rate you will pay throughout. Lenders who offer fixed rate secured loans include Pepper Money, Together, United Trust Bank and Shawbrook, among others.

The trade-off for this certainty is that you are locked into the rate for the term. If Bank of England base rate falls significantly after you have taken out a fixed rate loan, you will not benefit from lower payments — and if you want to exit the loan early, you may face early repayment charges. It is important to read the terms carefully before committing to a fixed rate over a long period.

How Variable and Tracker Rate Secured Loans Work

Variable rate secured loans charge an interest rate that can move over the life of the loan. Some lenders offer true tracker rates that follow the Bank of England base rate by a fixed margin — for example, base rate plus 5%. When the base rate rises, your rate and monthly payment rise by the same amount. When the base rate falls, your payment falls too. This transparency is one advantage of a tracker over a discretionary variable rate, where the lender can theoretically change the rate at any time at their discretion.

Variable rate secured loans are less common than fixed rate products in the secured lending market, but they are available from some lenders, particularly for shorter-term borrowing. Rates may start lower than equivalent fixed rate deals, reflecting the risk premium that borrowers pay for certainty on a fixed deal. If you believe interest rates are likely to fall over the term of your borrowing, a variable rate could cost you less overall.

The key risk is that your monthly payment is not guaranteed. If you are working to a tight monthly budget, an unexpected rate rise could cause payment difficulties. Before choosing a variable rate product, stress-test your finances against a potential rate increase of 2% or 3% to ensure your payments would remain manageable.

We've Helped Over 58,000 Homeowners
Save Money

Gary from London

"Easier Than Expected"

Gary, London
★★★★★
"I kept putting off remortgaging because I thought it would be a massive headache. Honestly, the whole thing was painless — filled in a quick form, got my options, and it was all sorted within weeks. Wish I'd done it sooner."
Katie from London

"Done In No Time"

Katie, London
★★★★★
"Our fixed rate was ending in a month and I was panicking about going onto the SVR. Managed to get everything sorted really quickly and we're now on a much better rate. Saving us about £200 a month."
Janet from Exeter

"So Much Better Off"

Janet, Exeter
★★★★★
"Was a bit nervous about switching as I'd been with the same lender for years. Turns out I was massively overpaying — got a much better deal and the whole process was far easier than I expected."
Lucy from Tamworth

"Happy Saving"

Lucy, Tamworth
★★★★★
"After having to pay a ridiculous amount due to the interest rate hike, we have now got a more suitable monthly payment, consolidated a loan and have money left for hopefully a loft conversion."

Which Lenders Offer Fixed and Variable Rate Products?

The majority of specialist secured loan lenders — including Pepper Money, Shawbrook, United Trust Bank, Masthaven, Norton Finance and Together — offer fixed rate products as their primary offering. Fixed rates provide lenders with more predictable funding requirements and reduce arrears risk by giving borrowers payment certainty, so they are the dominant product type in the market.

Variable rate secured loans are available from a smaller number of lenders. Together Financial Services has historically offered variable rate products alongside fixed options, and some smaller building societies and specialist lenders provide tracker-linked facilities. The availability of variable rate options can change over time depending on market conditions and lender appetite.

A whole-of-market broker will be able to tell you which lenders currently have variable rate products available and whether any of them suit your profile. Because the secured loan market is less standardised than the first charge mortgage market, it is more important to use a broker who has direct relationships with lenders rather than relying on comparison sites alone.

When a Variable Rate Could Be the Better Choice

There are several circumstances where a variable rate secured loan may be the more sensible option. If you are planning to repay the loan within two to three years — perhaps because you are selling the property or refinancing — a variable rate product may carry lower or no early repayment charges, meaning you keep more money on a short-term hold. The starting rate may also be lower, reducing your cost for the period you hold the loan.

If Bank of England base rate is at or near a historical peak and you believe rates are likely to fall over your loan term, a tracker product could produce lower average payments over the life of the borrowing than locking into a fixed rate at the top of the cycle. This is a judgement call that carries risk — rate forecasting is uncertain — but it is a legitimate consideration for financially confident borrowers.

Finally, if you anticipate making significant overpayments, a variable rate product with no early repayment charges may allow you to reduce your balance quickly without penalty. This can save considerably more than a slightly lower starting rate on a fixed deal where overpayments are restricted or attract a fee. Always confirm the overpayment terms of any loan before deciding between fixed and variable.

Important: Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage. There will be a fee for mortgage advice. The actual rate available will depend on your circumstances. Think carefully before securing other debts against your home.

Check Your Options in 60 Seconds

Free, no obligation, no impact on your credit score.

Check Your Savings Now →

Frequently Asked Questions

Switching from a variable rate to a fixed rate typically requires refinancing your secured loan with a new product, either with the same lender or a different one. This may involve early repayment charges on the existing loan, arrangement fees on the new product, and potentially a new valuation and legal process. You should weigh these costs against the benefit of locking into a fixed rate before deciding to switch.

Variable rate loans carry more payment uncertainty than fixed rate products because your monthly repayment can increase if the Bank of England base rate rises. The level of risk depends on how much rates could move and how much capacity you have in your budget to absorb higher payments. For borrowers with comfortable income headroom, the risk may be acceptable — for those budgeting tightly, a fixed rate is generally safer.

Many fixed rate secured loans do include early repayment charges, typically expressed as a number of months' interest or as a percentage of the outstanding balance. The charge structure varies by lender and product. Some loans are charge-free after a certain period, and a small number of fixed rate products are penalty-free from day one. Always check the early repayment charge terms before committing.

If the Bank of England base rate rises, your monthly payment on a tracker rate secured loan will increase by the same proportion. Lenders are required to give you advance notice of changes to your payment amount. If a rate rise would make your loan unaffordable, you should contact your lender immediately to discuss options rather than missing payments, which can damage your credit record and potentially put your home at risk.

For borrowers with adverse credit, a fixed rate loan often makes more sense because it provides payment certainty at a time when finances may already be stretched. Variable rate products can be harder to obtain for applicants with poor credit history, and the additional uncertainty of a changing payment could make budgeting more difficult. A broker can advise on which rate types are available to you based on your specific credit profile.